Album Review: Laura Nyro – Hear My Song: The Collection, 1966-1995

If the Mamas and the Papas were combined into one individual, or if Carole King were somehow genetically engineered to have commensurate talents but a different musical perspective, the end results might resemble Laura Nyro. An artist of staggering talent and individuality, Nyro was a first-rate songwriter on par with fellow artists like Harry Nilsson. In fact, like Nilsson, Nyro found much of her biggest successes when her songs were covered by other artists, and – ironically – when she recorded songs she didn’t write.

The former category of songs includes hits for Blood Sweat & Tears (“And When I Die”), Three Dog Night (“Eli’s Comin’”), Barbra Streisand (the exhilarating “Stoney End”) and The Fifth Dimension (“Stoned Soul Picnic”). Nyro’s gifts were recognized far and wide, albeit primarily within the music community. Even Paul Revere and the Raiders dug into the Laura Nyro songbook; their reading of “Save the Country” was a highlight of their criminally-overlooked 1970 LP Collage. Nyro’s work covered a great deal of stylistic ground; her most celebrated music could perhaps be best described as “secular gospel.” There’s a transcendent character to her lyrics, her voice, her instrumentation.

Fairly or not, most discussions of Nyro tend to center on her influence rather than her recordings. That’s understandable to a degree, as artists as varied as Todd Rundgren, Bette Midler and Suzanne Vega have all emphasized her importance and bearing upon their own work. Nyro’s reluctance to bathe in the spotlight – she rarely appeared on television, and there was that somewhat overblown legend of a supposedly disastrous live performance at 1967’s Monterey Pop – certainly didn’t help bring her to the audience she deserved. Nor did a nearly half-decade break in the early ‘70s and another in the 1980s.

But Laura Nyro’s body of work is substantial nonetheless; she released nine studio albums during her lifetime, and another album recorded in the mid ‘90s would be released in 2001, a few years after her premature passing. During her life, two albums of live material were released as well; five more would follow in the years after her death.

Hear My Song brings it all together in a dazzling package. 19 compact discs include all of the material enumerated above. Nyro’s early classic albums More Than a New Discovery (1967) and Eli and the Thirteenth Confession (1968) are featured in both mono and stereo; that’s significant, as those albums come from a time in which engineers created significantly different mixes for release. Nyro’s later releases – including 1984’s Mother’s Spiritual – are far less known but well worthy of discovery (or rediscovery) as well.

Massive and seemingly comprehensive as it is, Hear My Song is not an exhaustive compendium of Laura Nyro’s recorded works. To complete the set, one must also seek out Trees of the Ages aka Live in Japan, a document of a 1994 concert set first released in the Far East in 2003 but reissued by Omnivore Recordings in 2021.

That exception aside, Hear My Song remains a breathtakingly thorough collection of Nyro’s work. The 19CD set also offers up a host of previously-unheard goodies, including demos, live tracks and no less than two additional live concerts. Those feature a pair of San Francisco dates in 1994, recorded in two different venues but with similar set lists.

Listeners new to Nyro are advised to start with one of the many best-of compilations surveying her work. But after doing so, it’s likely that those listeners will find themselves wholly captivated by Laura Nyro’s artistry. At that point it will be time to plunge into the deep and immensely rewarding musical waters of Hear My Song.